This text was initially printed on by THE CITY. Join right here to get the newest tales from THE CITY delivered to you every morning.
Lori Gjenashaj leaned her automotive seat again, turned the radio up loud, and waited for the cops to reach on March 25, 2018.
Moments earlier, the mom of two had led police on a wild automotive chase via the streets of Staten Island. When the police arrived, she was carrying a starter pistol and now says she initially deliberate to beg the officers to shoot her.
It occurred anyway: police fired a bullet into her chest as she received out of the automotive.
The almost deadly interplay was the fruits of a weekend downfall triggered by a feud with a former buddy, copious quantities of medication, and a protracted historical past of psychological sickness tied to childhood trauma, in response to her associates and authorized protection group.
“For a second I simply needed to die, after which I began excited about my children,” she instructed THE CITY in an interview in October.
Now, almost 4 years later, Gjenashaj, 42, a former nurse, faces a battle in courtroom set to begin Jan. 19. She’s taking a look at as much as 15 years in jail for a collection of alleged offenses, together with menacing a buddy’s child with a starter pistol after the police chase.
The Staten Island district lawyer supplied a two-year plea deal shortly after the fees have been initially filed, in response to Gjenashaj’s authorized group.
However her supporters contend even a brief interval behind bars for somebody with complicated medical well being wants might be a loss of life sentence. Gjenashaj’s medical chart reads like a mixed record of just about unimaginable illnesses: lupus, flesh-eating micro organism from a historically low-risk surgical procedure and a fused backbone attributable to a automotive accident.
Her backers additionally be aware she has remained clear, and in remedy, because the confrontation with police. The trial has been delayed by the pandemic and a collection of authorized procedures.
Her supporters say the case touches on broader factors of how the NYPD handles calls like hers involving somebody present process a psychological breakdown. The administration of former Mayor Invoice de Blasio struggled to push ahead a program to pair EMT groups with social staff to deal with 911 calls citywide involving folks having a breakdown, with out dispatching cops.
Felony justice advocates additionally contend that folks with psychological sickness are higher served in applications with counseling outdoors of jail.
“I’ve been training legislation for 38 years and I’ve by no means had a case like this the place the DA’s workplace is so useless set on prosecuting somebody who has suffered a lot all through their life,” stated Joseph Licitra, supervising lawyer with The Authorized Assist Society’s Staten Island Trial Workplace, which is representing Gjenashaj. “In no world will sending Lori to jail serve any profit to public security.”
At the least one former metropolis jails chief agrees.
“The purpose of jail is both punishment and to get some normal deterrence. Neither a kind of suits this explicit case,” stated Michael Jacobson, the Division of Correction commissioner through the Giuliani administration.
“Jail ought to be used extremely parsimoniously,” he added. “What would two years in jail accomplish aside from ruining her life? You might have to have the ability to reply that.”
Staten Island District Lawyer Michael McMahon, by way of a spokesperson, declined to debate the pending case.
“Roughly 40% of all Staten Island tendencies contain defendant enrollment in a big selection of diversion programming, which DA McMahon established over almost six years,” stated his communication director, Ryan Lavis.
“These applications exist as a result of we acknowledge that addressing the underlying causes of legal habits is commonly a greater path ahead than incarceration,” he added.
A Downward Spiral
Gjenashaj’s supporters level out that greater than 120 folks have been dying in state prisons every year, in response to an October report by the Heart for Justice at Columbia College. The state jail system has additionally struggled to fill greater than 300 openings for medical workers, THE CITY reported in April 2020.
Her authorized group needs the case moved from legal courtroom to psychological well being courtroom the place judges have a greater understanding of such circumstances.
However not everybody needs to see her stay house.
Jennifer Harrison, founding father of Victims Rights NY PAC, stated she has “full religion” within the district lawyer’s choice and sentencing recommendations.
“I additionally hope that regardless of the end result, Lori Gjenashaj is just not rereleased into the group with out receiving the remedy and help she requires to not be a menace to herself, her household or the group,” she added.
Gjenashaj’s downward spiral was triggered by a psychological breakdown after her husband, Jimmy Gjenashaj, took away nearly all her ache remedy, in response to her protection group.
“I used to be attempting to assist,” Jimmy instructed THE CITY, noting his spouse started to battle with dependancy after affected by severe problems from surgical procedure in February 2015.
The cold-turkey method was a large shock to his spouse’s physique and psychological well being, her medical doctors stated. Earlier than her husband intervened, she was taking a harmful mixture of oxycodone, fentanyl and Xanax.
The police chase and pending legal costs was the fruits of years of battle for Gjenashaj and her household, her supporters say.
“Lori Gjenashaj is a girl who overcame unthinkable adversity nearly solely on her personal,” stated her Authorized Assist social employee, Sara Raftery. “She constructed a life and a household and had a profitable profession.”
However since 2012 “she has been dropped at her knees by a mix of trauma, bodily well being disasters, and psychological sickness,” Raftery added in a letter to the choose dealing with her case.
In 2012, the household’s three-bedroom duplex in Midland Seaside was significantly broken in Hurricane Sandy.
They moved again in after about six months, however two years later, a hearth broke out in a neighbor’s connected home. Firefighters broke the ceiling of their house and poured water inside as they tried to place out the blaze.
The household was as soon as once more compelled to depart for months.
“It was extra injury than Sandy as a result of the highest flooring was affected,” Jimmy Gjenashaj stated. “It’s nonetheless not mounted fully.”
After Sandy got here the flesh-eating micro organism.
In 2015, Lori went for the belly surgical procedure often known as a tummy tuck, a comparatively low- danger operation. However she observed shortly afterward that her wound website was infected. Six days later, she was admitted to Staten Island College Hospital with a 102.7 fever.
All instructed, she spent over a month within the hospital combating a uncommon flesh consuming micro organism known as necrotizing fasciitis. She underwent 12 surgical procedures and was despatched house with particular medical dressing over her stomach that required complicated remedy.
“I’ve a scar from behind every hip bone” all the best way to the middle of her abdomen, she instructed THE CITY. “I’ve a pretend stomach button. I had a giant pouch that sucked the micro organism into a giant canister.”
At house she was compelled to sleep in the lounge so she may attain the toilet and fridge whereas linked to the tubing machine. Simply strolling and respiration was painful, she recalled.
“I had stitches throughout,” she stated, noting her abdomen muscle tissue have been broken and wanted a separate operation in 2016.
“I used to be in a lot ache after that surgical procedure,” she stated. “My abdomen wouldn’t broaden.”
Medical doctors struggled to determine why she was in a lot agony. In 2017, a gynecologist found that some tissue was rising into the muscle of her uterus.
She wanted a hysterectomy and was prescribed opiates to take care of the ache. Her psychological state declined. She suffered from despair and often talked about suicide — and have become hooked on the ache remedy, in response to family and friends.
Her husband says he put in cameras in the home to verify she was OK and typically would race house from work to check out her.
She stopped working as a nurse at Staten Island College Medical Heart
At work, she as soon as began a drug abuse group to teach group members about the dangers of dependancy to ache remedy. “I used to be a giant advocate for teenagers and prescription drug abuse,” she recalled. “I may have by no means imagined what was coming subsequent.”
Fistfight at Faculty Play
The gradual downward spiral ended within the close to deadly police capturing.
The dispute that triggered that encounter was a seemingly run-of-the-mill argument with a guardian in her child’s class over a bunch science venture the day earlier than. In keeping with Gjenashaj, the opposite guardian needed to do the venture for the kids.
The subsequent day all of it escalated right into a fistfight at a faculty play on the Academy of St. Dorothy, in response to all accounts.
Gjenashaj received right into a bodily altercation with the mother — who she says initially pushed her. “We received damaged aside by a few of the fathers who have been there,” she recalled, noting she was requested by a faculty official to depart the efficiency.
She was phoned about half-hour later by police, who instructed her she left the scene of against the law and ordered her to report back to the native precinct.
“Earlier than I went to the police, I took a handful of Valium, about 30 or 40 tablets,” she remembered. “They put me in a holding cell and processed some paperwork.”
She was charged with legal obstruction of respiration for allegedly choking the opposite mom on the play, and given a desk look ticket.
As soon as launched, she went straight to the hospital for remedy on her neck, which was injured in a automotive accident just a few years earlier.
“I used to be actually tousled within the emergency room,” she stated. “I used to be excessive as a kite. I left with an IV in my arm.”
At house, she fell asleep however was woken by police who got here for a wellness test — seemingly due to the best way she fled the hospital.
Within the morning, her husband went to satisfy the principal on the college to verify the kids wouldn’t be thrown out over the struggle.
She was woke up by an investigator from town’s Administration for Youngsters’s Companies.
“Someone had known as and stated I punched my daughter within the face,” she stated. “This little woman is the air that I breathe. Simply the accusation made me sick.”
The ACS consultant requested to look at her two kids, each younger teenagers on the time, and ordered them each to carry up their shirts.
“At that time I form of blacked out,” she stated. “I used to be sexually molested as a baby and I swore I’d defend my kids they usually’d by no means have a life like mine.”
From that time on, Gjenashaj struggles to recollect a lot past the fundamentals: She grabbed the starter pistol and raced to the home of the guardian she fought with in school, satisfied that the girl made a baby abuse criticism in opposition to her.
She received in her automotive and started driving, all of the whereas wrestling her husband, who was attempting to cease her. A police officer noticed the dispute and tried to drag them over.
“For some purpose I didn’t pull over,” she stated. “As I used to be driving there have been extra cops.”
The police pushed her off the highway with their car, she stated, and approached the automotive with weapons drawn.
“I do bear in mind my husband being pulled from the automotive,” she stated. “As quickly as they did that, there was a small opening, so I took off.”
The police chased her up Hylan Boulevard as she drove erratically. She drove to the college guardian’s home close to Clove Street and banged on the door with the again of the starter pistol.
“I simply needed her to really feel violated as I simply did and my kids simply did,” she stated. She picked up a paving stone and tossed it on the door, knocking it open.
When she walked inside, the mom’s 13-year-old son was standing in the home.
“I do know this child since he was simply popping out of diapers,” she stated. She ordered him to name his mother and walked out of the home, paced backwards and forwards for a short time, and drove off.
She parked up the block and mirrored on what had simply occurred.
“I sat within the automotive and I may hear the police sirens and the helicopter and simply waited till they discovered me,” she remembered.
They ordered her out of the automotive parked on Highland Ave. close to Howard Ave. in Grymes Hill. Police say she was making wild gestures and pointed the gun at them. She says she put the gun on the ground of the automotive and got here out of the SUV along with her arms within the air — after initially considering committing suicide by cop.
Physique digicam footage from the officers who shot her is just not obtainable as a result of the cameras have been left on the precinct.
However one officer who arrived on the scene shortly after captured physique digicam footage of one of many cops who shot at her, joking about how he could be jammed up at work.
“I suppose I’m shedding my gun for some time,” stated an unidentified officer on the scene. The cops who shot her, Lt. Matthew Harrison and Police Officer Giancarlo Maratea, have been later honored for the way they dealt with the incident.
‘Face Down Bleeding within the Avenue’
Gjenashaj has filed a civil go well with in opposition to town and the officers concerned.. The go well with, filed in Manhattan federal courtroom, alleges the cops did not observe the NYPD’s coverage when dealing with so-called “emotionally disturbed individual” emergency calls.
Cops dealing with these calls are directed by the patrol information to make use of protecting shields and different non-lethal gadgets like tasers. They’re additionally required to hunt assist from a medical skilled if crucial and the individual’s household.
Gjenashaj’s husband, who was dropped at a close-by precinct, says he repeatedly instructed officers it was merely a starter pistol and begged officers to make use of warning along with his spouse.
She was shot as soon as via the chest regardless that “she posed no menace” to the 2 officers, the lawsuit alleges.
Afterwards, in response to the lawsuit, she was “handcuffed, subdued and forcibly held face down bleeding on the street the place she complained of ache from strain on her again being exacerbated by a NYPD officer’s foot on her again.”
She was dropped at Richmond College Medical Heart, the place she stayed for per week earlier than being transferred to Elmhurst Normal Hospital in Queens. She stayed in that hospital for 25 days, in response to the lawsuit.
Out on bail since April 2018, she has begun to commonly see a therapist and ache administration physician. Her life has change into secure, though she is unable to see her daughter with out supervision, her family and friends stated. The ACS probe revealed no proof of abuse, in response to her legal professionals.
However the legal trial looms and her family members worry an end result that would result in jail.
Any plea settlement would seemingly bar her from working as a nurse once more.“It’s been three and a half years now,” she stated. “I’ve been rehabilitated throughout the group. Sending me to jail goes to don’t have any constructive end result.”
Her husband added, “I do know she’s individual. She’s by no means gotten in hassle prior. She gained’t get in hassle after.”
THE CITY is an unbiased, nonprofit information outlet devoted to hard-hitting reporting that serves the folks of New York.
Recommend a Correction