A Mississippi clinic turned ladies away if that they had overdue payments

A Mississippi clinic turned ladies away if that they had overdue payments

Aubree Jordan of Madison has suffered from endometriosis since she was in center college. She was a daily affected person at The Girl’s Clinic in Madison, and noticed her physician as much as 5 occasions a yr. 

However after a surgical procedure on the clinic as a school scholar, she incurred a invoice she was slowly paying as she was in a position. Earlier than she might, although, she stated she acquired a letter from her physician stating she couldn’t come to her upcoming appointment till the invoice had been paid in full.

Jordan’s expertise was not a singular one — and definitely not at The Girl’s Clinic, the place triage nurses evaluate affected person data and play interference. If the affected person has a overdue invoice, nurses alert the billing workplace, and an worker then calls the affected person and asks for fee earlier than a nurse can return her name. This holds true even in circumstances the place the affected person has indicated on the telephone immediate that their name is an emergency. 

The clinic administrator for The Girl’s Clinic didn’t reply to Mississippi Immediately’s requests for clarification on the clinic’s insurance policies.

In response to specialists, this apply will not be unlawful and could also be taking place increasingly more usually. And it isn’t simply restricted to this supplier, as evidenced by testimonies from a number of ladies who spoke with Mississippi Immediately and use different clinics.

“My understanding is there’s no frequent legislation responsibility and even an moral crucial outdoors of the Emergency Medical Therapy and Lively Labor Act (which applies solely to hospitals) that requires a doctor to deal with each affected person,” stated Roy Mitchell, govt director of the Mississippi Well being Advocacy Coverage Program, which works on well being coverage points and advocates for customers, particularly those that are low earnings.  

However rising well being care prices and the added problems of insurance coverage reimbursements have introduced the difficulty to the forefront, Mitchell stated.

“Do physicians have an obligation to deal with? Sure, however solely on an expert, altruistic degree with none authorized power at this level,” he stated. 

Ken Cleveland, the chief director of the Mississippi State Board of Medical Licensure, stated in an announcement to Mississippi Immediately it might be unattainable to find out whether or not any violation occurred and not using a full investigation.

“Usually, the Board doesn’t get entangled in billing points. Nevertheless, the state of affairs you described (Jordan and others’ expertise) may advantage additional investigation if a proper grievance was filed,” stated Cleveland. 

Charles Miles, the previous president and present member of the Board of Medical Licensure, was extra forthcoming.

“That’s not proper,” Miles stated after listening to in regards to the sufferers’ tales. “I’m in OB-GYN (obstetrics and gynecology), and that’s not how we do issues.”

Endometriosis is a painful situation that happens when tissue much like that which usually traces the within of the uterus grows outdoors the uterus. When Jordan was a younger teen, her physician prescribed her a contraceptive that helps management the expansion of the tissue and the ache related to it.

However after two surgical procedures in subsequent years, Jordan, then a full-time school scholar with a part-time job, was struggling to repay her invoice on the clinic.

Sooner or later in 2017, the identical yr she had her laparoscopy, she acquired a letter from her physician through licensed mail at her household’s residence — and was startled by the tactic of supply.

The letter stated that until she was capable of repay her steadiness, which she remembers as being lower than $2,000, she can be unable to come back to her upcoming scheduled appointment. She had been anticipating to get refills of her prescription at that go to.

“I referred to as them up on the workplace and stated, ‘Look, I can not cease my contraception — (my physician) has me on a specific contraception that makes my endometriosis not flare, and I can’t simply cease taking it,’” Jordan, who’s now 26, stated. 

She stated her physician had additionally prescribed her an antidepressant following her father’s loss of life  — one more reason why cash was tight for her household on the time. 

Clinic staff didn’t provide her a fee plan and stated her steadiness needed to be paid in full to proceed seeing her physician. Jordan stated she then wrote her physician a letter and mailed it to him. Days and weeks handed, and she or he by no means heard again.

She finally discovered a brand new OB-GYN, however there was a wait earlier than she could possibly be seen. The ordeal resulted in her going months with out the medicine she’d been taking for the situation she had since she was in center college.

As anticipated, the endometriosis worsened.

“As quickly as they (the brand new physician) received me in, I used to be doubled over in ache,” she stated. “They lastly scheduled my surgical procedure. I used to be lacking lessons as a result of I used to be in a lot ache.” 

The coverage continues to be in place at The Girl’s Clinic, which is an unbiased, personal apply that rents area from Baptist Memorial Hospital and makes use of the hospital for admission of sufferers. 

Jacqueline Rudder, additionally of Madison, was shocked after she referred to as her physician throughout a medical disaster in early January 2022. Simply because the menu immediate directed her when she referred to as, she pressed “1” to point it was an emergency and left a message with the nurses’ station.

Inside minutes, she stated she received a name again from somebody within the clinic’s billing division. 

“The girl instructed me, ‘You can not speak to a physician or a nurse till you agree your steadiness,’” Rudder stated. “I wasn’t even conscious of the invoice on the time and would’ve been blissful to pay.” 

She later went and located the invoice in her mail. It was $51 and didn’t have a fee due date till subsequent month.

Rudder referred to as the billing division again the next week to ask them to make clear why that occurred to her. Mississippi Immediately obtained a recording of the decision, throughout which a billing worker instructed Rudder that’s their process. 

“In response to our procedures, we have now to attempt to care for the steadiness earlier than the nurse can name you,” the worker instructed her in a robotic voice. “The docs give you our procedures.” 

(Story continues under the picture.)
Jacqueline Rudder’s invoice from The Girl’s Clinic. Credit score: Mississippi Immediately

A number of different ladies, a few of whom requested to not be recognized by identify as a result of they’re present sufferers, have had comparable experiences on the clinic. 

When one tried to schedule an appointment for a process that her physician instructed her she wanted in December, she was knowledgeable she had a $500 steadiness and couldn’t schedule her appointment till it was paid. 

“I requested billing if they’d work it out to the place I might pay half then and half later, or $100 a month … however they weren’t prepared to work with me,” she stated. 

A number of years in the past, one other former affected person at The Girl’s Clinic was deemed high-risk and placed on mattress relaxation early in her being pregnant. She began bleeding sooner or later in January 2019 and referred to as the clinic instantly. 

Though she’d notified the clinic of a change in her insurance coverage because of her husband’s new job, she stated the primary name again she received from the clinic was from billing. 

“My OB’s nurse referred to as me hours later, and I got here within the subsequent day,” she stated.   

About 5 years in the past, one other former affected person discovered a lump in her breast one morning. She had a household historical past of breast most cancers, together with a grandmother who handed away from it. 

She referred to as the clinic in a panic. 

“I referred to as to make an appointment, and I don’t know who it was, however they stated, ‘Hey, you owe a steadiness, and we are able to’t see you, and you’ll’t communicate to a physician or nurse till the steadiness is paid,’” she remembered. “One other physician just about instructed me I’d been blackballed from the entire apply till I paid.”

She stated she determined at that time to search out one other physician. 

The Girl’s Clinic will not be alone in its practices, in keeping with accounts from ladies at OB-GYN and different specialty clinics. When Rudder posted her story of what occurred at The Girl’s Clinic on a neighborhood mother’s web page, there have been round 100 feedback, a few of which echoed Rudder’s expertise. 

A affected person at Ladies’s Well being Associates in Flowood instructed Mississippi Immediately throughout her physician’s visits whereas pregnant with twins in 2016, she was usually directed to the billing workplace earlier than having the ability to return to a room to see her physician — regardless of being high-risk. 

Shortly after giving start, she was having excessive ache in her C-section incision and made an appointment to see her physician.

“Instantly after I received there, they despatched me again to that room once more, and I used to be so mad as a result of I used to be in a lot ache,” she recalled. “I felt no one was listening to me in regards to the ache.” 

The invoice was lower than $100 and was not but due, she stated, however she needed to pay it to see her physician. Her physician finally carried out a process to assist relieve the stress in her incision, she stated. 

A consultant from Ladies’s Well being Associates stated she couldn’t touch upon the precise occasion since she didn’t know the id of the affected person.

“If a affected person has a steadiness and they should are available in for care … We communicate to them about fee preparations,” stated a clinic administrator, who hung up earlier than the reporter received her identify. “But when any person’s in ache, we’re going to care for them first.”

We need to hear from you!

Central to our mission at Mississippi Immediately is inspiring civic engagement. We expect critically about how we are able to foster wholesome dialogue between individuals who assume in another way about authorities and politics. We consider that dialog — uncooked, earnest speaking and listening to higher perceive one another — is significant to the way forward for Mississippi. We encourage you to interact with us and one another on our social media accounts, electronic mail our reporters straight or go away a remark for our editor by clicking the button under.

Republish our articles free of charge, on-line or in print, below a Inventive Commons license.


Republish this text

Until in any other case famous, you may republish most of Mississippi Immediately’s tales free of charge below a Inventive Commons license.

For digital publications:

  • Search for the “Republish This Story” button beneath every story. To republish on-line, merely click on the button, copy the html code and paste into your Content material Administration System (CMS).
  • Editorial cartoons and picture essays will not be included below the Inventive Commons license and subsequently do not need the “Republish This Story” button possibility. To study extra about our cartoon syndication companies, click on right here.
  • You possibly can’t edit our tales, besides to replicate relative modifications in time, location and editorial type.
  • You possibly can’t promote or syndicate our tales.
  • Any website online our tales seem on should embody a contact on your group.
  • If you happen to share our tales on social media, please tag us in your posts utilizing @MSTODAYnews on Fb and @MSTODAYnews on Twitter.

For print publications:

  • It’s a must to credit score Mississippi Immediately. We choose “Writer Identify, Mississippi Immediately” within the byline. If you happen to’re not in a position so as to add the byline, please embody a line on the high of the story that reads: “This story was initially revealed by Mississippi Immediately” and embody our web site, mississippitoday.org.
  • You possibly can’t edit our tales, besides to replicate relative modifications in time, location and editorial type.
  • You can not republish our editorial cartoons, images, illustrations or graphics with out particular permission (contact our managing editor Kayleigh Skinner for extra data). To study extra about our cartoon syndication companies, click on right here.
  • Our tales might seem on pages with advertisements, however not advertisements particularly offered in opposition to our tales.
  • You possibly can’t promote or syndicate our tales.
  • You possibly can solely publish choose tales individually — not as a group.
  • Any website online our tales seem on should embody a contact on your group.
  • If you happen to share our tales on social media, please tag us in your posts utilizing @MSTODAYnews on Fb and @MSTODAYnews on Twitter.

When you have another questions, contact Viewers Growth Director Lauchlin Fields.